The gulf of instantiation

By Gordon Rugg

Two of the most common complaints about managers and about teachers/lecturers are:

  • They’re too vague
  • They’re too specific

Although these complaints are opposites, the underlying problem for both of them is the same. It involves the gulf of instantiation, which is the topic of this article.

Continue reading


Education versus training, academic knowledge versus craft skills: Some useful concepts

By Gordon Rugg

At the heart of education theory is a widely used distinction between education and training. This overlaps with a closely related distinction between academic knowledge and craft skills.

Although these concepts are extremely important, there is widespread debate about just what they mean, and what they imply for education theory and practice.

In knowledge modelling terms, these two distinctions can be neatly represented using the concepts of closed sets versus open sets, and of connected graphs versus unconnected graph fragments.

The illustrations below show how this works, and what some of the implications are for education theory and practice.

Continue reading